Skip to main content
You have permission to edit this article.
Neustatter: For most, benefits of vaccine far outweigh the risks

Neustatter: For most, benefits of vaccine far outweigh the risks

  • 0

There are not many things I agree with President Donald Trump about. But the vaccine being what will save us from the COVID pandemic is one.

There is a catch, however. If enough people don’t get it, we won’t get herd immunity, and it won’t save us.

The Magic of Immunization

Hope is vested in immunization because they have “made the greatest contribution to global health of any human intervention apart from the introduction of clean water and sanitation,” according to a paper published by the Royal Society.

I don’t have to tell you. We have been in the grips of a pandemic that has screwed up our lives, work, schools, socializing, economy and harmony. This has caused heated debate over what restrictions are necessary.

The first two of six vaccines have reached prime time and seem miraculously effective, with an incredible 95 percent effectiveness. So, if we can immunize enough people, we can make this thing go away—like we have smallpox and polio. Or measles, which has gone from causing 2.6 million deaths worldwide, to 110,000 deaths in 2017.

If enough people don’t get it, however, we will not achieve herd immunity—a concept where there are too few susceptible people for the virus to get a foothold.

Experts have said about 70 percent of the population needs to be immune to achieve herd immunity.


The coronavirus vaccine is a moderately new technology, but simpler than previous technologies. It was first tried in animals 30 years ago. It involves injecting a small portion of synthetically produced COVID-19 messenger RNA.

The m-RNA is a “blueprint” that provides instructions to our cells to produce one of the proteins found in the surface of the COVID-19 virus. This protein then prompts the body to mount an immune response through a combination of antibodies, but mainly by sensitizing B and T lymphocytes. So if you are exposed to the virus, you get a rapid, vigorous response.

I think of it like the National Guard. Our T and B cells are ready to be called out at a moment’s notice.

Getting the shot often causes transient aches and pains, headache and fatigue—which really just tell you it’s working. Your body’s immune system is responding. But people tend to be unnerved by this.

Like any other immunization, or other kinds of shots, the vaccine can, very occasionally, cause a severe allergic reaction. But usually, such people will know to be cautious or avoid the shot from previous experience.

An important point is the RNA does not get into the cell nucleus, so it cannot alter your DNA, and thus your whole genome—which is one of the unfounded scares being promoted.

There are also claims that the shot includes a microchip that will be injected into your body and the “deep state” can track you. This is another misunderstanding. Sometimes the label on some prefilled syringes includes a microchip to record expiration date, batch number, etc. But this doesn’t get injected.

A large part of the resistance is a general “anti-vaxxer” sentiment. It seems all tied up with a general distrust of big government, the health care industry, vaccine manufacturers (especially since they got immunity from liability for vaccines) and a nebulous desire for freedom and autonomy.

But a lot of the distrust of vaccines is founded on misinformation—most infamous of which was the study by gastroenterological surgeon Andrew Wakefield, who was the lead author of a paper published in the Lancet claiming MMR shots cause autism.

These studies were debunked in short order after an outcry pointing out many flaws in the studies, and the Lancet printed a retraction. But that doesn’t seem to have stopped many from holding on to the idea.

You don’t usually think of the Lancet as being unreliable. But when looking for information—on any medical topic—it’s vital to go to a reliable source. I recommend the WHO Vaccine Safety Net ( for vaccine information. There’s also University of Southern California’s health site (, which gives advice on assessing the reliability of a site for any information.

Risk Versus Benefit

People ask me, “What do you think about this vaccine and are you going to get it?”

My answer is, “Every health care decision is a balancing act between the benefit and the harm.” The COVID vaccine is a relatively new method, but is theoretically safer than conventional immunizations that use part of a virus or bacteria, or attenuated whole organisms.

The 30 years of experience we have, and the lack of serious adverse effects reported from the trials so far, makes it very unlikely it’s suddenly going to come up with some fatal flaw. So the risk of not getting vaccinated, of getting COVID, seems a far greater danger.

People aren’t nearly as skeptical about the medicines they take. If anyone did as intense a risk/benefit analysis as people seem to be doing about the COVID vaccine, they’d probably never take any pharmaceutical ever again.

So, like Dr. Anthony Fauci and Vice President Mike Pence, I intend to get immunized at the first possible opportunity. And my message is, please do the same—even if you’re reluctant.

A vital point is this isn’t just about you. You can choose to take your chance with COVID, but if enough people are not immunized, it poses a risk to me—and anyone else who is vulnerable.

I don’t say this often, but do what Donald Trump is advocating.

Get immunized.

Dr. Patrick Neustatter of Caroline County is the author of “Managing Your Doctor: The Smart Patient’s Guide to Getting Effective Affordable Healthcare.”

Dr. Patrick Neustatter of Caroline County is the author of “Managing Your Doctor: The Smart Patient’s Guide to Getting Effective Affordable Healthcare.”

Build your health & fitness knowledge

* I understand and agree that registration on or use of this site constitutes agreement to its user agreement and privacy policy.

Related to this story

Most Popular

Get up-to-the-minute news sent straight to your device.


Breaking News

News Alert