Skip to main content
You have permission to edit this article.
COMMENTARY: Biden's Afghanistan extension is an unsurprising betrayal

COMMENTARY: Biden's Afghanistan extension is an unsurprising betrayal

  • 0
PHOTO: Troops in Afghanistan


NEARLY 11 years ago, then-Vice President Joe Biden swore on national television that all U.S. troops would be out of Afghanistan by 2014. U.S. troops continued to bleed and die there, however, and now President Biden says they’ll likely have to do it some more.

More than 13 months after the historic signing of the U.S.–Taliban peace agreement that would finally bring our troops home, Biden says the May 1 deadline for total U.S. withdrawal is just too difficult “in terms of tactical reasons.”

What tactical reasons might those be?

Is it the Pentagon’s failure to implement appropriate protocols for the transition of power in the more than a year’s time it had to do so?

Or is it the inability of Afghan security forces to defend themselves despite 20 years of training by the best soldiers the world has to offer?

Or, more likely, is it the Biden administration’s pet project of using the military to enforce American mores about sex and gender in Afghan society?

Or will the U.S. continue to use its allies as an excuse for keeping the military deployed in foreign adventures? Germany has declared that its mission in that nation will continue until 2022. Should the U.S. match them out of tactical solidarity?

Afghanistan does not need 2,500 American soldiers to stay through the year or longer. There is no tactical situation that will be solved in the coming year that will not also be replaced with a new crisis, and a new set of problems. The last 20 years of unmitigated suffering and resentment do not require some drawn-out, multi-part denouement as though the U.S. were wrapping up its own blood-soaked rendition of “Return of the King.”

It has been 20 years that we have been fighting there. It has been 15 years since the announcement of a democratic Afghanistan. And it has been more than a decade since the U.S. dragged NATO into its ill-conceived plan to rebuild the Afghan state in its own image.

The reward for all this has unsurprisingly been an empire of sand, bone, and global resentment.

Biden’s refusal to commit to the May 1 deadline that the previous administration set to bring the troops home and end this thing is a slap in the face to the troops who have carried this burden for two decades.

The American service member enlisted, did his or her job, and saw it through to the end. They should not be punished for the willful ignorance and dedication to antiquated strategic paradigms that their commanders and four consecutive presidents have refused to let go of.

Strategic ineptitude and influence peddling are truly bipartisan phenomena, and they are costing this nation dearly. As usual, the grunts will be the ones to pick up the tab.

Biden says he simply can’t picture our troops being needed in Afghanistan for more than another year. But after more than half of my life spent watching my countrymen die, I simply can’t picture them coming home.

Andrew Thornebrooke is executive editor of The Rearguard. He wrote this for

Catch the latest in Opinion

* I understand and agree that registration on or use of this site constitutes agreement to its user agreement and privacy policy.

Related to this story

Most Popular

The essence of local control is that residents of a particular jurisdiction should be able, through their elected representatives, to decide what public art is displayed. That means that residents do not have to be bound by the choices of past generations. But it also means that contemporary choices will also be subject to the same standard in the future, so memorials erected today may wind up being torn down tomorrow. Nihil durat in aeternum. (“Nothing lasts forever.”)

State legislators expressly excluded public servants who work for the commonwealth from their new public collective bargaining law for political subdivisions. They don’t want to have to deal with never-ending negotiations and demands for more money and benefits from state employees. And that should be an object lesson to all local jurisdictions that are considering taking lawmakers up on their offer.

According to the Rappahannock Electric Cooperative, one source is responsible for at least 1,000 power outages per year, which takes a large toll on the regional economy, and an even larger toll on residents’ peace of mind, as they never know if or when they will be targeted next.

The Fredericksburg City Council is now considering building a new school (which will cost upwards of $35 million) but council members admit that the only way to pay for it while still paying off the existing debt (which new school borrowing would increase by more than $2 million annually) is a major tax increase.

Always looking for ways to form a united coalition against the rising power of China, the U.S. has masterminded what’s called “the Quad” of four countries, including the U.S., Japan, India, and Australia. The common denominator for these four countries, all quite far geographically from one another, is their fear of China. 

Get up-to-the-minute news sent straight to your device.


Breaking News

News Alert