Skip to main content
You have permission to edit this article.
COMMENTARY: Cartons pave the way to fix struggling recycling system

COMMENTARY: Cartons pave the way to fix struggling recycling system

  • 0
PHOTO: Recyclable carton

SOME municipalities across the U.S. are struggling to sustain recycling programs that maximize the materials that can be placed in curbside bins. From New York to Washington State, Alabama to Utah, Arkansas to Arizona, and numerous points in between, localities have weighed trimming back their recycling efforts, underscoring broad-based dysfunction.

“The roiling of global markets for recycled material, municipal budget cuts, and in some places significant underinvestment in recycling infrastructure mean we are facing a critical juncture for recycling in the United States,” the Recycling Leadership Council said in a report released earlier this year.

“The system isn’t working as it should, with greater volumes of plastic and packaging lost to landfills, wasting valuable resources, or worse, leaking plastics into the environment.”

A coalition of industry groups, the council is calling for strong federal leadership to address the range of recycling issues.

One essential element for any federal fix must be to develop robust domestic markets for recyclables.

“This means improving the technology for sorting and recovering materials, incorporating more recycled material into products, getting these products into the marketplace, and creating demand for them,” said a Columbia University study from last year.

That’s the approach the U.S. food and beverage carton industry took in what serves as a case study for policymakers searching for solutions.

In 2009, regional materials recovery facilities, or MRFs, were reluctant to accept cartons for recycling. MRFs are the sorting centers at the local level that separate discarded materials, bundle them, and sell them as valuable feedstock to manufacturers.

Some MRF operators complained at the time the carton volume was too low to recycle efficiently, that it was too difficult to sort the cartons from other recyclables, or that an insufficient end market existed for the materials in recycled cartons.

Because MRFs didn’t have sufficient capacity to include cartons in their recycling programs, too many cartons were ending up in landfills.

So as an industry, carton manufacturers banded together to invest millions of dollars in improving MRFs—providing them new technologies that allowed sorting machines to better process cartons, thus creating a larger supply of the recycled cartons.

On the demand side, carton manufacturers shifted their attention to developing domestic markets for used cartons.

The fiber inside the cartons is highly valued for use in an array of products such as tissue, paper towels, and paper. The carton industry worked with the paper stock industry to define a grading system for cartons. Establishing the grading system helped spur demand for recycled cartons among U.S. paper mills.

The results are impressive. In 2008, only about 18 percent of U.S. households had access to carton recycling. But by 2014, after the carton and recycling industries teamed up, that had grown to 50 percent of U.S. households, as noted in a University of Michigan assessment.

Today, that figure tops 60 percent. Local communities are increasingly requiring that MRFs include cartons in their list of items when they bid for contracts, thus continuing to put upward pressure on carton recycling rates at the curb.

With Congress now debating measures to green the economy, mitigate climate risk, and improve the nation’s infrastructure, fixing recycling should be top of the list.

The success of carton recycling can serve as a guidepost.

Jeffrey Fielkow is president and CEO of Tetra Pak U.S. and Canada, which is based in Denton, Texas. He wrote this for

Catch the latest in Opinion

* I understand and agree that registration on or use of this site constitutes agreement to its user agreement and privacy policy.

Related to this story

Most Popular

Especially after the catastrophic learning loss due to the COVID-19 pandemic, disappointing public school rankings in the Fredericksburg region should be a wake-up call for parents, educators, taxpayers and public officials who spend the greater part of their city and county budgets on public education.

Removing those Confederate monuments in Richmond is not rewriting history. It is correcting history. No Virginia child, Black or white, will ever again be misled by grandiose statues into believing that leaders of an effort to keep people in chains are worthy of our adulation.

While it’s commendable that the USPS is trying to fix its logistical issues by hiring more people, the agency’s dysfunctional hiring process will result in some tough choices for America’s mail carrier. The USPS needs to get its other labor issues under control before getting more boots on the ground.

Get up-to-the-minute news sent straight to your device.


Breaking News

News Alert