Skip to main content
You have permission to edit this article.
EDITORIAL: SCOTUS closes gun seizure ‘loophole’

EDITORIAL: SCOTUS closes gun seizure ‘loophole’

  • 11
PHOTO: Supreme Court

A RARE unanimous ruling by

the U.S. Supreme Court has

closed what some analysts are calling a “loophole” in the Fourth Amendment’s prohibition of “unreasonable searches and seizures” by banning the seizure of firearms from a private residence without a warrant. It’s telling that all nine justices were united in calling out such warrantless seizures as unconstitutional.

Writing for the court in Caniglia v. Strom, Justice Clarence Thomas affirmed that the “very core” of the Fourth Amendment guarantees “the right of a man to retreat into his own home and there be free from unreasonable governmental intrusion.” Unreasonable is this case defined as the seizure of a man’s guns without a court-approved warrant—even though done with benign intent as a form of “community caretaking.”

According to court documents, the case involved Rhode Island resident Edward Caniglia and what he later claimed was a non-serious plea for his wife “to shoot [him] now and get it over with” after he placed a non-loaded firearm on their dining room table during a marital argument. There was no domestic violence or other crime committed, although the wife left the family home for the night and called police to escort her back the next day when her husband did not answer his phone.

The police convinced Caniglia (who insisted that he was not suicidal) to go for a psychiatric evaluation at the local hospital after they allegedly promised not to take his firearms. But while Caniglia was gone, they seized his two handguns without a warrant.

Noting that the Fourth Amendment allows some “unwelcome intrusions” on private property—including searches and seizures based on valid warrants, or when there is a need to “render emergency assistance to an injured occupant or to protect an occupant from imminent injury,” Justice Thomas wrote that police officers can still approach a private residence and knock on the door to ascertain if everyone inside is OK. But they can’t enter a home and seize property without a warrant.

Domestic disputes are one of the most dangerous interactions between police officers and citizens themselves, many of whom have been killed or wounded in such emotionally-charged situations. Requiring police to stop and obtain a warrant before they enter a private home and seize weapons allows a “cooling off” period for both sides.

In his concurrence, Justice Samuel Alito pointed out that the ruling also “implicates another body of law … the so-called ‘red flag’ laws that some States are now enacting.”

Those states include Virginia, which passed a red-flag law last year that allows police to seize a person’s firearms preemptively based entirely on another individual’s testimony that they pose a danger to themselves or others even if no crime has been committed, which puts many of these laws on thin constitutional ice.

However, unlike the Rhode Island case, the Virginia law requires that a warrant be issued by a judge or magistrate before any guns are seized, and such emergency risk orders can remain in force for only two weeks before the gun owner must be granted a hearing in circuit court.

Alito said that certain “provisions of red flag laws may be challenged under the Fourth Amendment and those cases may come before us. Our decision today does not address those issues.” But he left the door wide open for future challenges.

The ruling also does not address the question of whether the police can lawfully enter a private home without a warrant to do a “welfare check” on elderly or incapacitated individuals, as is customary in many jurisdictions.

“Our current precedents do not address situations like this,” Alito also pointed out. “We have held that the police may enter a home without a warrant when there are ‘exigent circumstances,’ but circumstances are exigent only when there is not enough time to get a warrant, and warrants are not typically granted for the purpose of checking on a person’s medical condition. In the meantime, courts may be required to grapple with the basic Fourth Amendment question of reasonableness.”

As will all 50 state legislatures.

Catch the latest in Opinion

* I understand and agree that registration on or use of this site constitutes agreement to its user agreement and privacy policy.

Related to this story

Most Popular

According to the “Crime in Virginia 2020” report released earlier this month by the Virginia Department of State Police, there were a total of 537 homicides throughout the commonwealth in 2020, up from 455 in 2019. And African American males disproportionately made up more than half of all murder victims.

Social scientists who study family dynamics are discovering (or rediscovering) the “Dad Effect”—which describes the tangible, measurable benefits children enjoy when they have an emotionally engaged and physically present father in their lives.

Despite his bias, Judge Benitez probably got it right about the unconstitutionality of an assault weapons ban, and his ruling is a good predictor of the result if the issue ever reaches our conservative Supreme Court. The right to have a weapon for self-protection precedes the Constitution, a right so “natural” that the founders didn’t bother to secure it by language any stronger than the slender reed of the Second Amendment.

Customers in deregulated states pay on average nearly 40 percent more than Virginians, according to the Energy Information Administration. For example, a Wall Street Journal analysis found deregulated Texas consumers paid $28 billion more for their power since 2004 than customers of the state’s traditional utilities.

Garrison Keillor’s weekly assertion on “A Prairie Home Companion” that all the children living in the fictional of Lake Wobegon were "above average" was a gentle poke at American parents’ belief that all their offspring are special. It was not meant to be a blueprint for school systems in the real world.

Get up-to-the-minute news sent straight to your device.


Breaking News

News Alert